Two traits I’d drill into at any finance interview
1) The ability to change your mind when new evidence comes to light.
2) The ability to readily admit and own a mistake.
In my experience, these two things make a massive difference.
If you have a finance team that can embrace new ideas, challenge their own thinking, change their opinions and admit when they’ve made a tiny boo-boo (or a right royal c0ck-up), you’ve got some pretty solid foundations for a winning formula.
There are two key reasons.
1 – Holding opinions too firmly can be expensive.
If your FD looks at the numbers and they suggest a particular narrative, that’s useful management information. But the real skill is marrying what the numbers suggest with what people across the business are saying has happened, is happening or is likely to happen.
And vice versa.
Business leaders might be suggesting one version of events while the numbers are telling a completely different story. The trick is being able to hold an opinion firmly, but not so tightly that you can’t let go of it.
To have the confidence to challenge, but also the humility to be challenged.
Going out with the pack, blinkers firmly attached, with the sole aim of convincing everyone else that their interpretation is wrong is rarely the optimal strategy.
Don’t get me wrong.
Sometimes the numbers absolutely SHOULD be used to challenge assumptions, cut through the noise and bring people back down to earth. But they rarely tell the whole story. And it’s difficult to bring the wider context into play if you’ve already become welded to your conclusion before all the facts have washed onto the table.
2 – Mistakes happen. All the time.
In every business in the UK. Big and small. And they’re made by everyone. You. Me. Your colleagues. Your boss. Your team. Them’s the breaks.
Sometimes the mistake is tiny and relatively insignificant. Sometimes it’s an absolute clanger. The sort that has a material impact on time, money, credibility or all three.
Of course, a good finance team should be striving to minimise mistakes through robust processes, procedures and controls. But no matter how tight the ship, errors will happen.
People will stuff up.
And having complete trust that the people around you will put their hands up, in real time, when something goes wrong is wildly valuable. Because mistakes themselves are often solvable.
It’s the concealment, the delay, the finger-pointing and the desperate attempts to sweep things under the carpet that can turn a manageable problem into a right royal mess.
I’d much rather employ someone who makes the occasional mistake and owns it than someone who spends their life trying to convince me they never make any.
So, here’s my thought of the week.
If you’re interviewing for a finance hire at the moment, consider slipping in a couple of questions:
“Tell me about a time you were absolutely convinced you were right about something, but subsequently changed your mind. What happened?”
And:
“Tell me about a mistake you made that had a meaningful impact on the business. How did you handle it?”
I’d be very interested in the depth and ownership of the answers.
Because in my experience, the best finance professionals aren’t necessarily the people who are right all the time. They’re the people who are willing to recognise when they’re wrong, do something about it and learn from the experience.
Happy Thursday.
If you have recruitment needs in finance that require specialist support, I’d always welcome a brew or a Teams.
Thanks as always for reading.


