How to Successfully Recruit a Financial Controller
Having a superb ‘number two in finance’ can be an absolute game changer.
It frees up the CFO / FD. Gives them the time and space to get stuck into strategic planning, board-level influencing, commercial decision-making and the real ‘tip of the sword’ added-value work.
Rather than spending half their life reviewing reconciliations, chasing month-end deadlines and firefighting operational issues.
But finding, attracting and (crucially) retaining a great FC / Head of Finance can sometimes be easier said than done.
And I think one of the biggest mistakes businesses make is assuming there’s a single ideal profile.
There isn’t.
Broadly speaking, you’ve got a few options:
- The ambitious up-and-comer. Someone who ultimately wants to become an FD. They’re hungry, motivated and see the FC role as an important stepping stone.
- The career FC. Someone who has reached FC / Head of Finance level, enjoys it, is bloody good at it and is perfectly happy staying there.
- The former FD. Someone seasoned who has operated at FD level themselves but fancies taking a step back into a chief support role. Perhaps they want less pressure, fewer board meetings or simply a different work-life balance.
- The practice candidate. Someone making their first move into industry, bringing strong technical foundations but potentially needing support adapting to the commercial and operational realities of an SME.
- The emerging talent. Perhaps a Management Accountant or Financial Accountant who’s ready (or nearly ready) to make the step up.
Obviously, people aren’t quite as straightforward as five neat categories.
Someone might be perfectly happy at FC level for the next four years because of family commitments, but have ambitions to progress once their circumstances change.
Someone else might have been an FD for ten years but have absolutely no desire to do it again.
The important thing is understanding what makes your candidate tick. And being brutally honest about what your business can offer them.
1. Don’t sell a career path that doesn’t exist.
If you’re looking for someone ambitious who wants to become an FD within the next 3–5 years, can you genuinely offer them that opportunity?
Maybe you can.
Perhaps you’re growing through acquisition and they’ll eventually become FD of a division.
Perhaps you’re the current FD, with ambitions to become MD, and they’ll step into your shoes in your slipstream.
Or perhaps you spend four brilliant years together. They make a huge contribution, you equip them with the experience and skills they need, and you both accept that you’ll happily shake hands in 2030.
There’s absolutely nothing wrong with that. Not every successful hire needs to stay for ten years.
What doesn’t work quite so well is dangling the carrot of an FD position that, in reality, is never going to materialise. You might get them through the door. But good luck keeping them.
2. Don’t mistake ambition for suitability.
There’s sometimes an assumption that the best candidate is the one with the biggest career aspirations.
I’m not convinced.
Imagine you’re an FD who absolutely loves the strategic and commercial side of the role but has little appetite for the operational nuts and bolts.
You need someone who’ll take complete ownership of the finance function. Someone who loves controls, processes, managing the team, producing accurate numbers and making sure the wheels don’t fall off.
A technically brilliant, experienced FC who genuinely enjoys that responsibility might be worth their weight in gold.
They might have no interest whatsoever in becoming an FD.
And that’s absolutely fine. In fact, they might be a far better long-term appointment than someone who’s desperate to get out of the operational detail and into the boardroom at the earliest opportunity.
Sometimes the best number two is someone who doesn’t actually want to be number one.
3. Be realistic about the support you can offer
If you’re considering someone making their first move from practice, or a more junior candidate stepping up, think carefully about the support they’ll need.
Have they managed people before?
Have they dealt with a difficult month-end, an underperforming team or a set of systems held together with spreadsheets and goodwill?
Can they confidently challenge operational managers? Have they actually owned the numbers rather than simply reported them?
None of these things should necessarily rule them out.
Some of the best FCs I’ve come across have been given an opportunity before they looked completely ready on paper. But there needs to be a sensible balance between stretch and support.
If you’ve got an experienced FD who’s happy to mentor them, brilliant.
If you’re expecting someone to arrive on Monday, inherit a dysfunctional finance team, sort out the systems, improve cash flow and deliver perfect management accounts by Friday…
Well, perhaps the ambitious step-up candidate isn’t quite what you need.
There’s a difference between giving someone a fantastic development opportunity and throwing them so far into the deep end that they get sucked under and drown.
4. Recruit for where you’re going, not just where you’ve been.
This is another big one. You might be a £20m business today with relatively straightforward reporting requirements.
But what does the next three years look like?
Are you planning acquisitions? International expansion? A new ERP system? Private equity investment? A significant increase in headcount?
The FC who’s perfect for a steady £20m business might not necessarily be the person best equipped to support a £50m+ group with multiple entities and increasingly complex reporting requirements.
Equally, there’s little point paying a premium for someone with extensive M&A and group consolidation experience if the business has no intention of doing either.
Think about the problems you need solving today, but also the challenges you’re likely to face tomorrow.
5. Get clear on what a brilliant working relationship actually looks like.
For me, this is perhaps the most overlooked bit. An FD and FC can both be outstanding accountants and still make a pretty ineffective partnership.
How come?
Because their strengths, expectations and preferred ways of working don’t complement each other.
If the FD is a big-picture thinker, commercially driven and impatient with detail, perhaps they need an FC who’s structured, methodical and happy to challenge them.
If the FD is highly technical and detail-oriented, perhaps a commercially confident FC who can engage with the wider business would add more value.
There’s no magic formula. But it’s worth asking yourself: “What do I need this person to be better at than me?”
And perhaps more importantly: “What am I genuinely prepared to let go of?”
Because there’s little point recruiting a brilliant FC to take ownership of the finance function if you’re going to insist on checking every journal, approving every decision and interfering in every process… You can’t recruit someone to take responsibility and then refuse to give them any authority.
The bottom line:
There are some superb Financial Controllers out there.. Ambitious ones. Experienced ones. Technical specialists. Commercial operators. Future FDs. Career FCs.
But the best candidate isn’t necessarily the most qualified, the most ambitious, the most experienced or the one with the most impressive CV. It’s the person whose capabilities, motivations and ambitions align most closely with what your business genuinely needs and can realistically offer.
And getting that right starts long before the first interview. Spend some proper time thinking about the profile. Challenge your assumptions. Be honest about the opportunities and limitations. Use your recruiter as a sounding board. Because that time invested at the front end can honestly make an enormous difference. Trust me – it really impacts the chance of success.
Not just your chances of recruiting the right person. But, more importantly, to your chances of keeping them.


